Top 10… Animated Disney Movies

PinocchioWell look at that, I’ve gone and been on the Lambcast again. This week’s episode saw myself, Nick, Kristen, Dylan and, via pre-recordings Pat, discuss the Disney renaissance, the nine films released by Disney from The Little Mermaid to Tarzan. The show ran a little long – two and a half hours in total – but it’s well worth a listen. Anyway, to celebrate, here’s my list of the top 10 animated Disney films. I haven’t included any of the films Disney has made with Pixar, or any of their non-animated efforts, this list is just cartoons.

Honourable mentions:

frogvillainOf the 52 animated feature films Disney has released, I can remember having seen a total of 22 (and I’ve not really heard of eight of them. I’m pretty sure I’ve seen some of the other ones, but I can’t for the life of me recall anything about the likes of Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Alice in Wonderland, The Fox and The Hound or even Dinosaur, a film I should justifiably adore because of the subject matter, and one that I’m pretty sure I saw at the cinema. Therefore, there’s a total of twelve films outside of the top 10 that are eligible for the Honourable Mention slot on this list. Of these twelve, I think it’s going to be shared between Pinocchio and The Princess and the Frog. Pinocchio is a classic, the second feature length animation Disney released after Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. The story is a bit nuts – a toymaker wishes on a star and his latest marionette comes to life, before going on a series of adventures that involve smoke-ring-blowing mammals, boys being turned into donkeys and eventually everyone being eaten by a whale – but the animation is great. The Princess and the Frog may seem an odd choice too, but I liked the idea of a strong, independent heroine who had a dream and intended to work hard to achieve it, and the villain – voiced by Keith David – is one of my favourites from Disney.

10. Mulan

mulan2Before watching it for the recent Lambcast I’d only seen small sections of Mulan before. I hadn’t been blown away, and therefore didn’t expect too much from it, however I was pleasantly surprised by what I saw. Clearly Eddie Murphy has been cast as Mushu the dragon in an attempt to recreate the Robin Williams effect from Aladdin (which we’ll get to later), but he doesn’t quite capture the magic. However, this film has some great musical numbers, particularly I’ll Make A Man Out Of You, which of course is set to a training montage, and in spite of a fairly predictable plot (something you need to take with a pinch of salt when it comes to Disney), this is a thoroughly enjoyable little film.

9. The Little Mermaid

Flounder-and-Sebastian-little-mermaid-ariels-beginning-1602539-485-324Remarkably before watching it for the Lambcast I’d never seen The Little Mermaid before, however I knew all the words to Under The Sea, and happily sang along to them all. Storywise this film is fairly bland – spoilt princess gives up her entire life and everyone she knows to be with a man she’s only met for a few seconds, and a man who enjoys eating her friends for that matter – but Ursula the mermaid/octopus/nightmare is wonderfully evil, the songs are great and the supporting characters very memorable, most notably Sebastien the crab.

8. The Sword in the Stone

stone45-06

You know those films that you are absolutely certain you’ve seen literally dozens of times before, but that you can’t quite remember exactly what they’re about. Well The Sword in the Stone is exactly this kind of film, however I’m also certain that I really like it. A couple of YouTube videos later and I’ve confirmed this theory. The videos in question? The wizard battle in which Merlin and Madam Mim transform themselves into various different animals, including a snake, crab, alligator and huge-ass dragon in a wizarding duel, and some scenes in which Merlin and the young King Arthur are squirrels being hounded by female equivalents. Yes, it’s mental, but it’s also good fun, and I’ll definitely be tracking this one down for a re-watch soon.

7. One Hundred and One Dalmatians

1961, ONE HUNDRED AND ONE DALMATIANSJust like The Little Mermaid, this has earned a place mainly because of the villain, Cruella de Ville, who has become a cinematic icon for cruelty and villainy, and has a theme song almost as recognisable as Darth Vader’s. The film itself has its moments – the dog/owner comparisons, the puppies’ escape – but De Ville is easily the film’s highpoint.

6. Tangled

tumblr_m834il6Et21rrv57ko1_500

The most recent entry on this list, Tangled is also the only entirely digitally animated entry, and also the one I’ve seen the least/longest ago, as I’ve only seen it once, and at the cinema. When I saw it, however, I really enjoyed the revised take on the Rapunzel story, particularly the bar scene, with the gang of ruffians singing about their loves in life, including small ceramic unicorns. The final scene, involving hundreds of floating lanterns, is also one of the few scenes I think would be actually worthwhile to see in 3D, although I probably never will, because I just hate 3D so very much.

5. Aladdin

Thereturnofjafar308On the surface, this is just another mildly racist run of the mill poor boy meets rich girl and they fall in love anyway story, but when you add in Robin Williams’ wise-cracking Genie, Jafar’s Peter Cushing sucking a lemon face and some innovative uses of magic, plus a tirade of terrible puns during the climax, you get a film elevated above its plot. Which is good, because otherwise I’d still be hung up on things like Jafar owning a hypnotising sceptre, but not using it to hypnotise Princess Jasmine into marrying him. The songs are also great, and I can’t get the tune to Prince Ali out of my head, despite barely knowing any of the words.

4. Robin Hood

Robin-Hood-disney-19380586-1706-960This film would have fallen into the same category as The Sword in the Stone in terms of how much I could remember it, if I hadn’t spotted it second hand for a few pound a few weeks ago. Yes, I broke my not buying new DVDs until I’ve watched all the ones I’ve got that I haven’t seen yet rule (which needs a snappier name), but well, this wasn’t exactly the first time I’ve broken that, and it was for a bargain. I watched it a couple of nights ago and found the whole thing flooding back to me, particularly the chase that breaks out after the archery competition, during which a tent-full of rhinos charge around with not just an entire stone castle on top of them, but two elephants inside said turret as well. The villain here is Prince John (voiced by Peter Ustinov), a pathetic mane-less lion with mother issues and a tendency to suck his thumb. In terms of Robin Hood adaptations, this is probably my favourite, unless you count one scene of Time Bandits.

3. The Jungle Book

all4happyThe Jungle Book is most definitely one of the films from my childhood, as it’s one of the four or five films my family owned on VHS. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen it – something it has in common with the remaining films from this list. It could be the sheer (Kahn) volume of viewings that make me love it so much, but on my most recent viewing (a year or two ago) I still really enjoyed it, particularly the banter between Baloo, the laidback bear, and Bagheera, the more uptight panther charged with looking after Mowgli the man-cub as he grows up. Kaa the snake is also brilliant, and King Louie the orangutan who wants to be a human so he can set fire to things, I think.

2. Beauty and the Beast

gastonAh, Beauty and the Beast. The one film on this list that I really should own, given how much pleasure I get from watching it. From the stained glass window prologue, to the “Bonjour” song, the dancing cutlery, the wood chopping machine, everything. And Gaston is one of my favourite villains of all time. Every thing he says and does is brilliantly, up to and including his song, to which I am slowly learning all of the words. I had some issues with the film – if you think about it too much, the Beast was cursed for not letting a stranger into his house when he was 10 years old, something I don’t hold against him considering his parents are nowhere to be seen either – and the ending is a little too soppy, but these things can be forgiven when everything else is so much fun.

1. The Lion King

341065927_smallThis is it – the first film I ever remember seeing, the beginning of my love affair with the movies. Although to be honest, the most memorable part of that first cinema trip was in fact the McDonalds Happy Meal afterwards, which may also have been my first, I don’t know. Anyway, I love The Lion King. I love the soundtrack – I Just Can’t Wait To Be King, Be Prepared, Circle of Life, Hakuna Matata, these are all songs I happily sing along to whilst cycling to work. I love the voice cast – from Rowan Atkinson as fussy hornbill Zazu to James Earl Jones presiding over as King Mufasa, and especially Jeremy Irons hamming it up and taking great pride in his words as the villainous Scar. I love the musical numbers, particularly the ludicrously choreographed I Just Can’t Wait To Be King, which someone organised half the jungle just to leave Zazu stuck under a rhino. I love the animation, especially in the stampede sequence, the moment when Disney finally worked out how to properly integrate digital animation into their films, unlike the awkward carpet ride through the caverns in Aladdin or the overly-glossy ballroom dance in Beauty and the Beast. And Rafiki, I love Rafiki. He isn’t in much of the film, but when he is he’s awesome.

rafikiSo what do you think? What would make your list? Do you like the more modern work, like Wreck-It Ralph (which I still somehow haven’t seen), or more classic fare like Cinderella or Peter Pan? Or perhaps you prefer the more experimental work, like Fantasia, which I’m not personally that big a fan of, but have recently found I need to give a second chance to. Let me know in the comments.

About these ads

11 thoughts on “Top 10… Animated Disney Movies

  1. Obviously you are more into the modern Disney fare and I agree that your top 5 is good stuff. On my list I would definitely find a place for Pinocchio and Dumbo, both of which are outstanding. Cinderella would hit the mark as well. I liked Fantasia better than you did but if you compare it for watchability it probably falls short of the other ones. It should be taken in small doses.
    Good overview, I do not think I can recall 22 Disney films

    • Thanks! I definitely prefer some of the newer films than the older fare, but for the most part I haven’t seen a lot of the older ones. I like Dumbo, but I don’t love it, and Cinderella is a film I’m pretty sure I’ve seen but can’t remember any of.

  2. Well, I could argue that Alice in Wonderland deserved a viewing before making the list, but it’s okay. You’ve invested enough time in watching Disney films lately.

    Robin Hood is awesome, and I’m so glad you included it since it seems to be forgotten in most cases.

    Sword in the Stone is phenomenal, and extremely underrated as well. Just ask John Lasseter. It would be higher on my list. I can’t disagree with the list at all. Although, you could include Wreck-It-Ralph at this point, right?

    • I’d love to include Wreck-It Ralph, but alas I’ve still yet to see it. You can look forward to assigning it to me!

      Robin Hood was a favourite of an old university house mate of mine, and for all I know he’s still trying to track it down on DVD. The Disney vault really is a kill-joy sometimes.

      Alice in Wonderland seems familiar to me, but that could be more to trips to Disneyland Paris when I was a kid, where there’s lots of Wonderland stuff. I’m not sure I can take another Disney film for at least a few weeks, so I didn’t even try to track it down.

  3. I am blushing over here that you so very kindly linked over to my Fantasia piece. Thank you very much for that.

    I definitely go in for the classic 2D animated fare from the Disney repertoire.

    Very good list. I like your inclusion of The Jungle Book (especially ranking it so highly), Robin Hood, and The Sword in the Stone, as these are the classic animated Disney movies that I find tend to be overlooked, and I’m very fond of all three. I read the book “The Once and Future King,” as The Sword in the Stone is based on the first portion of that book, and was very pleasantly surprised to discover that Disney altered surprisingly little when they adapted it. Cinderella was a big part of my childhood, but it’s not really a favorite of mine anymore. I’ve never been too keen on The Lion King, as it fell in an awkward place in my cinematic life, essentially just as I had left children’s films behind was super eager to delve into “grown-up” movies. Plus, honestly, if I wanted to watch Hamlet, I’d just watch Hamlet, I don’t need to watch African Lion Animated Hamlet. Which is not to say that it isn’t a good movie, I think it is, it’s just not my cup of tea and it never captivated me in the way it apparently captivates everyone else in the known universe. I think that means I have no soul or something. Oh well.

    I really like The Little Mermaid, but I hate the utter Disney-fication of the ending. Beauty and the Beast rocks.

    But Sleeping Beauty is a huge favorite of mine because, and I know you’ll laugh here, of its classical music score. Yes, yes, me and my classical music, but hear me out. Disney took Tchaikovsky’s Sleeping Beauty ballet and adapted the music to fit the film, essentially adding lyrics to create the songs and using the rest as background score. I have no problems with this whatsoever – in fact, I think it’s a brilliant way to introduce children to classical music. Tchaikovsky’s Sleeping Beauty is a phenomenal piece of music, and it really elevates Disney’s Sleeping Beauty with its power and evocative beauty.

    • You’re more than welcome for the link, seeing as your Fantasia review is one of the best reviews of anything I’ve read recently, it’s the least I can do. Plus it means you won’t be annoyed with me for not including Fantasia on my list.

      Personally, I prefer African Lion Animated Hamlet to proper Hamlet, but that’s possibly because African Lion Animated Hamlet features a hornbill voiced by Blackadder singing It’s A Small World After All.

      I looked into the original Little Mermaid ending for the Lambcast, and I’d have loved Disney to use that, and I’m sure many psychiatrists would have too, if only for all the therapy they’d be giving to people who saw it as a child,

      Apparently I need to watch Sleeping Beauty! I’m not surprised in the slightest that your reason for recommending it is a classical score; I’m beginning to think those are the only films you like!

      • Ha ha ha, no no no! No, I like all kinds of movies!!!!

        BUT if classical music is significant in some way in a movie, then I am heavily predisposed to liking it. It’s a thing with me. Definitely a little weird, but those are my cinematic tastes. I think I just get excited that classical music is finding its way into a pop culture medium, thus exposing more people to it, and I like that.

        The original ending to The Little Mermaid is awesome and dark and gory and WHAT THE HELL DID THAT JUST HAPPEN IN A FAIRY TALE? And in Disney’s ending, she’s wearing a poofy wedding dress. What up with that. Oh well, the songs are still rockin’.

      • I’ll forgive your classical music obsession if you forgive my dinosaur one.

        And am I right in saying the original ending saw Prince Eric laughing as Ariel’s tail was split open and she bled to death?

      • to your question below about the ending of The Little Mermaid, yes. Accounts differ as to what the true source material is, but it all involves the mermaid surrendering to death in some rather horrific way in order to preserve the prince’s life, and he’s not even that worthy of her anyway. It’s kinda messed up. But as a kid, that’s what I loved so much about fairy tales, that they WERE a bit brutal and violent and didn’t always end happily.

  4. Great list! Cinderella will always be my favorite animated Disney film. I just love that movie to death. And Aladdin… seriously, how much fun is that movie? Amazing.

    • Thanks Alex! Apparently I need to watch Cinderella! And yes, Aladdin is a great film, although I can’t get the memory of the lesser TV series out of my head!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s